before i keep debating the flash issue i want to make sure you understand my target market. it's 18s to twenty-somethings involved in a culture that is more about looks, design, personal expression than having to click one extra time. yes lack of functionality will turn them away also, but i don't feel i have that problem with my site... yet... haha.
? maybe not, but if it's worth putting on the site it should be readable
unless it's put on the site as a design aspect. you still saw it and then investigated to figure out what it said, i'd say it's working exactly how i wanted it to.
? you will see a yellow box appear [I think something can be simulated in Flash - ask Aaron.]. It's achieved via the alt/title tags in HTML
oh yeah, i know all about alt tags. i thought you may have been talking about something else. i don't think any button should need an alt tag unless it's purely graphical, like my three bottom links(TDN link etc.). i know how to do the same effect in flash i just don't want to.
? Getting to anywhere from anywhere is possible with or without Flash and you should be able to get back to the previous page without having to remember its location. Plus if pages are within pages [sub levels of navigation] people have to do a lot of clicking to return to where they were - it's said you loose something like 10% of your customers per click extra they have to go though.
i agree this is one area that flash fails in. i just try and make up for it as best i can through the archeticture of the site. that's why i have spent tons hours completely on the information archeticture of the sight. at any given time you are no more than two clicks from any page.
in regard to the Amadeo cart:
? very slow to load or use [I'm on broadband too]
it loads as fast as any given html page. the page transitions are slow, but that is how the mood of that site is set. those animations are set at the speed purposefully.
? there is no mention of sizes [what is Large etc.], can't see enlargements, back prints etc
mention of sizes? the shirt size? it's on the left with all the other details. it says "select your size" and then has check boxes for S M L XL. The reason it doesn't show back prints is because there aren't any. and there is a zoom function on the right side that allows you to zoom over the entire photo.
? can't enlarge text and have to wait for each section to load [I spent more time watching the loading screen]
what do you want to enlarge the text for? as a designer i'm glad this can't be done because i want the user to see it how i intended them to see it. on an html page you have to watch it load also. at least with flash you can pass the time watching a nifty little animation opposed to images randomly loading on to your screen.
?
http://scene360.com/tshop/a_tshop.html is a better example, done without Flash
this cart is horrible! i'll keep it short to the main points, but i could tear this one apart. the biggest thing with this one is it sends you to a third party site! you add one thing to the cart and you're sent to some other site(that doesn't even match cosmetically) showing what's in your cart. i usually buy more than one thing, now i have to either click back a few times to get to the main store front or... wait... look... a "continue shopping at scene 360" button! i'll definitely use that... no wait... it just sent me to the home page for scene 360. how often do you go to the market, bring your cart to the back dairy section, and a gallon of milk, then walk all the way back to the front of the store before going back to the dairy section and adding eggs in to your cart? this site was not a good example.
? and the best on-line shopping site has to be Play.com.
this site does work well. i still believe the Amadeo site can keep up with this one and i also prefer the Amadeo site cosmetically over the Play site
? Plus book marking something for later isn't recommended with Flash.
bookmark? what do you mean? like bookmark your shopping cart page to check out later? no need to book mark your shopping cart page. add an item or two to the Amadeo cart and when you return your order is still in the bag. click on the bag and you're checking out.
? I think the key is the more products/product lines you have the less likely it is Flash will work for you - Flash with a few t-shirts you can do [assuming everyone has the plug-in], but if your doing a shop [t-shirts, shorts, snow boards, dvd's etc.] then Flash should be avoided.
i think it can be done, and done very well. and i'm gonna do it just to prove it to you. hahaha.
plus i would like to see an html site that can incorporate video as smoothly and sleek as flash can.